The Crucial Role of Initial Consideration in Shaping Consumer Choices

Brands continually seek innovative strategies to understand and influence consumer behavior. The digital age has ushered in a new era, prompting businesses to explore novel avenues for engaging their target audience. Key elements reshaping the retail ecosystem include Retail Media and Visibility, crucial aspects to consider when reimagining brand consideration strategies, where the message conveyed must be sufficiently clear to leave a lasting impression on consumers. This article delves into the intricacies of these concepts, drawing insights from McKinsey's report, "The New Battleground for Marketing-Led Growth," to unravel their significance in comprehending how consumers transition from brand awareness to purchase and loyalty.

‍

Consumer Decision Journeys (CDJs)

Central to understanding consumer behavior is the concept of Consumer Decision Journeys (CDJs). Traditionally, marketers followed a linear path, assuming consumers progressed from awareness to consideration, purchase, and loyalty in a straightforward manner. However, in the digital era, CDJs have become more dynamic and non-linear.

Consumers now embark on journeys that involve multiple touchpoints, from online research and social media exploration to in-store experiences. Retailers must adapt their strategies to meet consumers at various stages of their journeys, tailoring their approach to provide relevant information and incentives.

Despite significant investments by companies in loyalty programs, there is mounting evidence indicating a decline in the strength of consumer connections with numerous brands. This is underscored by a decrease in engagement with loyalty programs, with a notable 58 percent of loyalty members failing to utilize the programs they have enrolled in. (If you want to read more about the impact of existing customers, link here).

‍

Shopping Around

McKinsey researched over “30 categories and only 3 were loyalty driven, with consumers predominantly making the same brand choices from one purchase to the next rather than shopping around. In the other 27 categories, consumers exhibited strong shopping tendencies”.

The challenge of capturing loyalty implies that marketers should shift their focus towards the moments when consumers are in the early stages of deciding which products or services to purchase. It necessitates the most effective strategies to be part of what is referred to as the initial consideration set.

The integration of Retail Media into the shopping experience has emerged as a pivotal factor. This channel involves brands paying for visibility on retailers' websites, leveraging their online presence to connect with consumers actively seeking products or information.

Digital Shelf Optimization plays a crucial role in this scenario, ensuring that a brand's products are prominently displayed and easily discoverable. Brands that invest in optimizing their digital shelf presence enhance their chances of catching the consumer's eye during critical decision-making moments.

‍

Importance of Initial Consideration

The battle for consumer attention often begins with the Initial Consideration phase. With 87% of consumers displaying robust shopping tendencies, the efficacy of loyalty-driven strategies is being called into question. In the broader context, 69% of the brands acquired by consumers who opted to switch brands were originally included in their initial consideration set when they commenced their shopping journey. This is where Retail Media becomes a game-changer, allowing brands to secure prominent placements on digital shelves and stand out in the crowded marketplace. Share of Ads, measured by the visibility a brand achieves through paid placements, becomes a key metric in this phase.

By understanding and influencing the consumer's Initial Consideration set, brands can significantly impact their likelihood of being chosen during the later stages of the decision journey. The ability to strategically position products at this stage can set the tone for the entire consumer experience.

‍

‍Customer Growth Indicator (CGI)

The Customer Growth Indicator (CGI), an integral metric that amalgamates consideration and market share, emerges as a pivotal factor elucidating sales growth. McKinsey emphasizes the significance of CGI, asserting that it should serve as a benchmark for evaluating brand health. In supporting this notion, McKinsey provides insightful graphics, sharing visual representations that underscore the correlation between CGI and sustained sales growth, thereby reinforcing the metric's importance in assessing the overall vitality of a brand.

‍

To enhance CGI, brands must focus on maintaining visibility throughout the entire decision journey. This involves optimizing Share of Ads, Share of Spend (the proportion of the marketing budget allocated to a particular channel), and Share of Search (the brand's visibility in online searches).

‍

Marketing Budget Rebalancing

There is a growing recommendation for Marketing Budget Rebalancing, urging companies to allocate more resources to initiatives that enhance initial consideration while trimming expenditures on less impactful strategies such as sales incentives and loyalty programs. The overarching objective is to leverage the expansive reach of digital channels in spotlighting distinctive offerings that compel consumers to delve deeper into the brand, fostering consideration and engagement.

The shift towards digital channels, Retail Media, and Digital Shelf Optimization necessitates reallocating resources to channels that deliver the highest impact on consumer decision journeys. 

By rebalancing marketing budgets, brands can align their investments with the changing dynamics of consumer behavior, ensuring a strategic and data-driven approach to visibility and engagement. This adaptability is crucial in an environment where consumer preferences and technology continuously evolve.

‍

Conclusion

In conclusion, understanding how consumers move from brand awareness to purchase and loyalty requires a holistic approach that incorporates Retail Media tools. Brands must strategically position themselves during the Initial Consideration phase, leveraging their Visibility with early ads in the customer journey, maintaining high shares in Search and Shelf, and offering promotions in line with the market.

By embracing these concepts and leveraging McKinsey's report, brands can not only navigate but also thrive in the complex web of consumer decision journeys, fostering lasting connections and driving growth in an increasingly competitive market.

For more information on standing out above competitors in the Initial Consideration phase, we invite you to connect with us!

‍